Ballin & Associates
  • HOME
  • ABOUT
    • Philosophy
    • Practice Areas >
      • Motor Vehicle Accidents
      • Wrongful Death
      • Brain Injuries
      • Workplace Injuries
      • On-Duty Police Injuries
      • On-Duty Firefighter Injuries
      • Defective Premises
      • Slips, Trips & Falls
      • Injuries to Children
      • Defective Products
      • Assaults
      • Negligent Security
      • Inadequate Warnings
      • Inadequately Trained Employees
    • Attorneys >
      • Steve Ballin
      • Richard Miller
      • Paul Johnson
      • Zachary Ballin
      • Jared Ballin
    • Results
    • Compensation
    • Referrals
    • Charitable Giving
    • VIDEO VAULT
  • PERSONAL INJURY
  • POLICE
    • Areas of Practice >
      • Cruiser & Motorcycle Accidents
      • Stolen MV Pursuits
      • Directing Traffic
      • Road Jobs & Other Details
      • Resisting Arrest & Protective Custody
      • Defective Premises
      • Dog Bites & Knockdowns
      • Domestic Disputes
      • Foot Pursuits
      • Injuries During Rescues
      • Ice & Snow
      • Shootings
      • Toxic Substance & Disease Exposure
    • FAQ's
    • Departments Served >
      • Testimonials
    • Workshops
    • Results
  • FAQ's
    • I Was in Crash. Now What?
    • Choosing a Lawyer
    • Compensation
    • Filing a Claim
    • Types of Accidents & Injuries
    • Do I Have to go to Court?
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT

$150,000 FOR OFFICER EXECUTING SEARCH WARRANT

3/21/2017

 
PictureWarrant in hand, the police search an apartment and seize a bag filled with heroin. A job well done but they still must get past the snow-covered steps on their way out.
A landlord’s tenant is the subject of a drug investigation by a joint task force.  With three knock and announce narcotic search warrants in hand, the police enter the landlord’s multi-unit rental property through the front entrance without incident.  The police search the tenant’s second floor apartment.  The police find a bag filled with heroin and the tenant is taken into custody.

While leaving the building, a local police detective slips and falls on snow and ice covered granite steps attached to the front porch.  As you may know, it is often more dangerous coming down icy stairs than going up.  The detective suffers a complete rupture of the patella tendon in his left knee.  Less than two weeks later, he had surgery under general anesthesia to repair his knee.  The detective’s condition improved with time and despite some continuing symptoms, he was cleared for a full return to work just over five months after his fall, including a short stint on light duty.

We have been making a habit of stressing the importance of documenting ice falls with photographs right away.  This case was no exception.  Similar to a case we reported on a few months ago, a fellow officer took plenty of photographs to document the condition of the stairs soon after the detective’s fall.  The photos clearly showed the front entrance covered in a thick layer of hard packed snow and ice.  In addition, the photos indicated an absence of any gutter system to direct melt water away from the roof above.  The absence of gutters allowed melt-water to drip down and refreeze to form melt water ice on the front entrance.

The photographs were critical in enabling us to settle the detective’s case with the defendant’s landlord for $150,000 without having to file a lawsuit.  Had we needed to involve the Court, the photographs would have been a crucial part of the case.

Aside from the importance of photographs, here is the takeaway for public safety officers around the state – landowners must keep their property safe for visitors where people are expected to walk.  Moreover, this holds true regardless of why you are legally at a property.  Whether it be responding to a domestic call, serving a search warrant, or anything in between, it does not change the fact that you are a lawful visitor and the landowner has a continuing obligation to make it safe for you to walk on the property.

That said, Massachusetts law is reasonable.  It recognizes we live in New England.  There is no expectation that every speck of snow and ice be removed from someone’s property.  The law does, however, impose a duty on landowners to use reasonable care in all circumstances.  Typically, this involves shoveling after a storm or putting down sand or rock salt on icy areas.  This photograph tells another story: the landowner chose to neglect the buildup of snow and ice, endangering all visitors to the property, including emergency responders.

To protect the privacy of the detective and witnesses, all names have been changed.  Any resemblance to names of real persons, past or present, is merely coincidental and not intended.

– Jared N. Ballin, Esq.

The injured detective agreed to have this article published in order that public safety officers around the Commonwealth be better educated about their legal rights to compensation when injured.

$6 MILLION PAID TO FAMILY OF OFFICER KILLED ON DETAIL

3/21/2017

 
PictureA contractor’s poorly planned work site cost a police officer his life. After years of blaming everyone else, lies were exposed and the contractor paid.
A contractor parks two large utility trucks back to back while setting up for an ongoing project on Main Street at an intersection with Booth Street.  There is heavy traffic in this area with vehicles approaching the work site from multiple directions.  Many of the vehicles pass alongside the two trucks and crew, while others come out of Booth Street entering the intersection from the north and south on either side of Main Street.  The contractor hires Officer Jeffrey to work this detail.  No other detail officers were hired.

Later that morning, two drivers approach the southbound lane of travel on Booth Street from different directions: Mr. Green approaches from the west (green car) on Main Street and Mr. Reach approaches from the north (red car) on Booth Street.  Facing west alongside the first truck, Officer Jeffrey directs vehicles past the trucks on Main Street.  Mr. Reach then crashes into Mr. Green’s vehicle as it passes by Officer Jeffrey.  Reach’s car then veers into Officer Jeffrey.  Officer Jeffrey is pinned against the contractor’s truck and killed.  Officer Jeffrey never saw Reach’s car approaching across the intersection from Booth Street.

The State Police investigation focused on Mr. Reach.  He was charged with and pled guilty to vehicular homicide.  There was, however, no investigation made regarding the contractor’s traffic control plan.  Nevertheless, I believed that the contractor blocked the southbound lane on Booth Street without planning for or warning traffic.  Therefore, I filed a lawsuit not only against Mr. Reach, but also against the contractor.

Photographs released after Mr. Reach’s criminal case was over confirmed that one of the contractor’s trucks blocked the entire southbound lane on Booth Street.  And after dozens of depositions, I discovered that besides Officer Jeffrey, the sole officer hired for the detail, the only traffic control devices utilized by the contractor were two ‘work ahead’ signs on either side of the work site on Main Street and a few cones alongside the two trucks.  As often happens to officers hired on details, Officer Jeffrey was left to cope with the confusion, congestion, and traffic as best he could in this busy, four-way intersection.

PictureOne of the contractor’s trucks blocked the entire southbound lane on Booth Street.
The contractor’s crew leader testified he filled out a job brief form before occupying the work site, which detailed the traffic control plan.  Suspiciously, the contractor lost that document.  I also discovered two of the contractor’s supervisors were at the work site long before the crash.  Each was responsible to train the crew on setting up traffic plans for work sites.  Conveniently, neither supervisor could recall what the set up was for this work site.

The four crew members and two supervisors then testified the truck did not block the southbound lane of travel on Booth Street.  Fortunately, the responding officers took hundreds of photographs of the scene, two of which clearly depicted the truck blocking the entire southbound lane on Booth Street.  I used these photographs to impeach each of the contractor’s employees.  I also confronted them with the contractor’s own manual for setting up its work sites.  All four crew members, including the two supervisors, were unaware their own manual had a specific diagram detailing how to set up a work site with a blocked lane of travel on one side of a four way intersection.  Finally, I got each of the contractor’s employees to admit no warning signs were put out on either side of Booth Street.  Warning signs about a change in the traffic pattern would have prepared drivers like Mr. Reach before he ever got to the intersection.

From the outset, the contractor refused to accept any responsibility for the crash which killed  Officer Jeffrey.  Instead, the contractor put all the blame on Mr. Reach.  However, the law recognizes that both the contractor and Mr. Reach are responsible if a jury concludes both their negligent acts contributed to cause Officer Jeffrey’s death.  After taking numerous depositions, chasing down documents and the retention of expert witnesses, I was able to prove the contractor’s negligently deficient traffic plan contributed to the crash.  Following mediation and just months before trial, the contractor and Officer Jeffrey’s estate agreed to settle this case for $6 million.  While I am deeply saddened for Officer Jeffrey’s family, I am grateful they now have the financial resources to support themselves for the rest of their lives.

– Steven M. Ballin, Esq. & Jared N. Ballin, Esq.

To protect the privacy of the deceased officer’s family and witnesses, all names have been changed.  Any resemblance to names of real persons, past or present, is merely coincidental and not intended.  The deceased officer’s estate agreed to have this article published so police officers around the Commonwealth can be better educated about work zones and their legal rights to compensation when injured.

    ARCHIVES

    October 2018
    July 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    January 2018
    August 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    October 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    September 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013

    CATEGORIES

    All
    Featured Articles
    Insurance
    Jared Ballin
    Mass Heroes
    Paul Johnson
    Police
    Results
    Richard Miller
    Steven Ballin
    Zachary Ballin

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.